Does God forbid us from forcing unregenerate people to act morally? This question has exploded on social media, and today we are going to distinguish and bring some clarity around the different roles and callings that God has for different officers, church officers versus the civil magistrate. Well, you're joining us today on the magistrate, and I'm your host, James Baer, joined by Josh Howard. Josh, how are you doing today? I'm doing well, man. How are things in Florida? Oh, things are good. Things are great. Good. We're not trying to rub it in. Not trying to rub it in. I know. Yeah, we're doing the whole, we're doing the whole, you know, it's going to pour rain for the next week, and it might be snowed, it might not, and you might get 12 feet, and we'll see what happens. But before we get rolling, and I'm really excited about this topic, do want to mention our sponsors, we're sponsored by rockwallbibles.com. So please check out Rockwall Bibles. You can reach out to Adam. It's a family-owned and operated business in the Ozarks. Rockwall has weekly releases, I think weekly. Anyway, very regular releases of new Bibles, and you can get either a new one, or you can get one of your old Bibles rebound, make great gifts for loved ones. So check out Rockwall Bibles, use that code EM10. Rockwall Bibles will also be along with steadfast cigars. They will be sponsors at our upcoming conference. So if you've not heard about the EM conference, there is an EM conference coming up in April. It's going to be April 22nd through 24th in 2027, and that'll be at Sovereign Grace Family Church in Jacksonville, Florida. That's Keith Foskey's Church. If you're familiar with Keith Foskey and his channel. But yeah, we'll be down there in April. You can check out all of the speakers and topics that we have lining up. And I think Rockwall Bibles is giving away a Bible, and I think steadfast cigars are giving away some sort of bundle anyway. If you are registering for the conference, it is going to be limited seating on purpose. So you want to get those seats as early as you can. Use the code Howard in your checkout, and that will give you a substantial discount. If you use any of the other conference speakers names, I've been told it actually adds to your total cost. So it's a penalty. If you use anybody else's, so you want to make sure to use Howard in that, in that checkout code. So yeah, come join us at the conference. It should be a great time. But let's move into our topic to juror. Let's talk about this quote. And I want to just kind of set the the tone for the quote a little bit. The quote came from Todd Freel. So Todd Freel is a public Christian voice he has hosted. I think things for Liggy Nier over the years, things like that. He also has a show that's called wretched radio. Many people used to tune in. I've listened to a few of them over the years. I think a lot of people stop listening to him around the pinwheels controversy during COVID and all those sort of things. But anyway, Todd Freel is sort of a vocal voice. And the way the reason I wanted to engage this quote. So one of the things we try to do on EM is to engage the thing being said, and we're not trying to come after people. So we have no interest in trying to tear down Todd Freel as a person. But I think the thing he said is really wrong in a really interesting way. And the reason I use that quote by the way, when I was in seminary, one of the actually this is in the doctoral program. One of the other students was complaining that we had to read so much Rudolph Boltman. So we were just, you know, neck deep and German higher critical thinking. And this, this student was like, how much Boltman do we need to read? And we had this old professor and he was awesome. He was just like a floating head with a body attached to him. And this professor, he leaned back and he said, well, Rudolph Boltman is often wrong. But he's wrong in some very interesting ways. I was like, that's that's pretty good. I'm going to, I'm going to take that. So Todd Freel was wrong and he was wrong in a very interesting way. So this is, this is the quote and James, you referenced this a minute ago and then I'll kind of hand off the baton to you a little bit. Oh, you're requesting me to share here. There we go. Here I want to share, wait, wait, I want to share some people can see it if they're watching on YouTube and also cause Steven's going to make an appearance here. Okay. There we go. So yeah, there's the, there's the quote. So the quote was, or the post rather was, it is easy to be frustrated by moral decay, but forcing unregenerate people to behave more morally as a solution God never, never gave us. Very interesting. I shared it. I think, I think a whole host of people shared it. The reason I think it's really wrong in some really interesting ways is because I don't think that this is a very obscure opinion. I think Todd Freel probably shared it because I think a lot of Christians would read that and think, yeah, I am frustrated by moral decay. Number one, and if you're a Christian, you should be frustrated by moral decay. That doesn't mean you're supposed to be, you know, bound up in the moral decay of the society around you to the point that it's debilitating or sinful or anything like that, but at the same time, you should care about your society. I want my children to grow up and Lord willing, my grandchildren to grow up in a world that's not openly hostile to the Christian faith that doesn't promote and celebrate things that God says that He hates. So we should be concerned about moral decay and the world around us, but this is the part, the second part is the the the part that is I think very wrong in a very interesting way. Forcing unregenerate people to behave more morally is a solution God never gave us. James, walk us into this a little bit. Great. So yeah, this is a great quote to teach. Oh, and by the way, before you get going, you've got to unscreen share that at some point or that's all people will see on the video, I believe. Oh, great. Yeah, I forgot about we had that video error on the last last episode. All right. Well, everyone can screenshot this for themselves. Okay. So this is actually a great quote to use to teach people some really important distinctions in reformed theology, also Christian jurors, prudence, and general. So we're going to break down a few words used in this phrase. First one is forcing. Next one is unregenerate. After that is behave morally and then a solution God gave or never gave and then so actually I want to write all that down. So I make sure I actually expose the things the way I said, hold on everyone. You will benefit from allowing me to take notes. So first of all, what did I say, forcing, let's talk about forcing unregenerate, behave more morally, solution God gave or didn't give and then us. All right. This is great. The us is going to do a lot of heavy lifting in this. Yeah, it's exegesis. So let's before we get to where should I start? I'm just going to work it actually in that order. So let's find out. I'm fine with that. Okay, great. So let's talk forcing. What do you mean by forcing? You can talk about force in many different senses. So the first one we might call moral force. What does that mean? It means that you are such a startling example to everyone in your community that everyone wants to be like you and no one wants to not be like you. Okay, moral force. The next one you could talk about is physical coercion. That's very simple. If you do something that I said not to do, I will beat you, kill you, throw you in jail, something like that. The next step of force we could talk about would be incentives. Okay, so that would and that could be positive reinforcement or negative reinforcement. This could be something like you're going to get a tax benefit if you do this or you're going to lose the tax benefit if you do this other thing. So there's various different types of incentives that could be used. The next one we're going to call this type of force discounted in-sing. Discounted in-sing. What does that mean? Basically means if you do something bad, people are going to look at you sideways and may not come over to the barbecue when you invite them. Okay, those are I would say the four different types of things that people could do that is a type of false force or compulsion. Moral force, physical coercion, incentives and discounted in-sing. Okay, so we are talking about forcing someone to behave a certain way. It's always very important to distinguish exactly what you mean. That's first thing we'll say. Regenerate, unregenerate. Can I add into that by the way? Yes, please. We talk about force and it's going to be inevitable that I'm going to accidentally jump the shark a little bit and start talking about us on accident. But we talk about moral force. When we talk about the framing of the tweet and the whole discussion is about civil society. So we're not talking about the church. We're talking about the state, the magistrate. Again, we're going to get into some of those things in a minute. I would suspect, but if you're to look at forcing someone to behave, the church in one sense based on the categories that James laid out, you could say the church has a force that it exerts. The force of the church is to be ministerial and declarative. The church ministers word and sacrament, the church exercises discipline. So when we when we excommunicate, which is a horrible and a tragic event, wherein somebody is removed from the church visible with the hopes that they will repent and turn from their sins and come back and join the the fold should God work in their heart. But when excommunication is exerted, that is a that is a type of force. It's not the same as the force of the state. And yet at the same time, there is a sort of force within the church. The state, on the other hand, by definition, is required and called by God to use force. It's it's called to wield the sword. It's called to punish what is evil and to reward or promote or countenance what is good. So you have a force exerted all throughout society, but specifically we're talking about as the force of the magistrate, but yeah, exactly. So moral force, let's break moral force down into two subcategories. Moral force could be by example, it could be by persuasion. Okay. And moral force is the force wielded by the church. Right. The church only has spiritual declarative power. It can set an example. It can persuade you, but that's it. So we were proven review can exhort. We don't whip church members when they miss church on a Sunday. That's everything. Yep. That's right. That was a great illustration by the way, James. I don't feel like you appreciated that illustration. I thought that was pretty good. Go ahead. I thought that I'd be a judge. You're rolling. No, no, I was about to have. There was a Holy Spirit holding back my tongue from being funny. I hear you. Moral force, example or persuasion. Okay. Physical coercion, incentives, discounted and sing. All right. So now let's talk about the unregenerate. But there's a very important distinction. Performed to theologians have always made in the ways in which regenerate people may or may not be moral or virtuous. Okay. The first one is civil virtue. Okay. We could also call this yeah, civil virtue. The next one is spiritual virtue. Okay. Whenever we say that the unregenerate person can do no good, we were saying they can do no no spiritual good. We are not saying they can do no civil good. Okay. So they help old ladies across the street, but they do it for some other motive besides glorifying God. All right. There are forts of no spiritual value. Right. Not honoring in the side of God, not truly good in the spiritual sense of good and yet good for society. It's better for them to help an old lady across the street than to shuffle in front of a car. That's good. That's right. That's good. So the unregenerate are able to perform civilly virtuous acts. All right. Next one. Behave morally. When typically in this context, when we're talking about behaving morally, we're talking about civil virtue. And notice what he said there is so important. Behave behaviorally. He even uses the word there, which makes this quote so problematic. Right. We can talk about inner morality and outward morality. Okay. Another important distinction. Inward or inner inward morality. Outward morality. Okay. What do we want to think about this? This is what happens whenever you go the speed limit, even though it's a ridiculous speed limit, you should totally be able to go 10 miles faster. Okay. You are, your heart is rebelling against the civil statute of the speed limit. And yet outwardly, you are behaving morally. So that's an important distinction to make. It's important for this. Inward and outward morality can actually still fall into the category of civil virtue. What I mean by this is you can follow the speed limit and genuinely mean it to honor your authority without doing that in a way that honors God. So when we talk about civil virtue, we're not just, we're not only talking about outward morality. We're talking about inward morality and outward morality that is good in a civil way, even if it's not pleasing to God, it means that you are actually happy to obey your civil authorities. You in fact do obey your civil authorities, but you're still not doing it for God's glory, that civil virtue. So don't collapse civil virtue with just outward behavior. It actually does include a disposition of the heart that is correct from a civil perspective. It's just not correct from a God word biblical perspective because there's still not doing it for God's glory. In other words, you have lots of great patriots who for love of country lay down their life, but did not do it for the honor of Christ. Okay. So they weren't just virtuous outwardly. They were also virtuously virtuous, virtuous inwardly. Just not in. They just didn't do it by faith. And without faith, it's impossible to please God. So go ahead, Josh. No, I was going to say, yeah, this is an important distinction because if you, you know, like my sons and I love to, you know, watch and read about World War II and about the revolutionary war and lots of lots of, we just like wars. I mean, we don't like wars, but we like studying, you know, history and all those sort of things. You read those, those accounts and you know of many examples where guys jumped on top of grenades, ran into gunfire through themselves and harms way to protect a comrade. And they're doing so out of a love for their brother and out of a virtuous, I don't know if I'd want to use the word virtue, but there is a, there's a goodness there, right? And yet at the same time, you could say, well, many of those men were not Christian. They certainly weren't doing it for the glory of God. Yet there was some sort of good at play. What, what Freel's quote is doing, and this is again, one of the, one of the areas in which I find it interesting or wrong in a really interesting way is that it starts to collapse everything into the work of the church or the work of God's people. So all of a sudden, the only goods we can talk about are those goods which are heavenly oriented, those goods which are born from a regenerate heart under the glory of God. Now we want that, we want people to do things because they love God. This is why we witness and this is a part of the work of the church and making disciples of all the nations. And yet at the same time, that's not to collapse everything into one kingdom or one realm or one sphere to where all the distinctions are collapsed to where you would look at it outward society and say, there's actually no good in people choosing to not murder each other and choosing to help the old lady across street. Like no good exists if it's not a good that ultimately glorifies God. And that is to sacrifice, that is to sacrifice good for the best. It is best and it is what we want to lead people to to honor God with their actions. And yet at the same time, it's better for all involved, including them and including those around them if they're still doing good things in society. That's right. That's exactly right. Yes. Now we're going to get to the thing Josh is dying to get to. The us. It's unavoidable. It's unavoidable. It's right there. Yep. So us, God, so actually no, I skipped one. I'm sorry. Solution God gave. We're doing talking about that for solution God. So God gave, yes, how win and where? So God gives us thing by things, by nature or by grace. Okay. So I've been gifted with being six feet by nature. You know, I didn't grow an inch or shrink an inch when I believed in Jesus. That's a gift God gave me by nature. God made you the size of an effuling by nature by grace. Okay. It is, it is the funniest thing to me that this still bothers you. How bothers the heck out of me. I like my whole world would be changed. Now, where now that those are the means by which God gives them either by nature or by grace. But where are those things communicated? Okay. Well, gifts given by nature are communicated through natural revelation. Gifts given by nature and by grace are both actually communicated in scripture. Scriptures are only places you can find grace, but you find nature there too. So in scripture, you learn about nature and grace and nature, you only learn about nature. Okay. But we've got to distinguish between the means that God uses to give something and the means by which God communicates to us that he has given it. Okay. That's important. Very important. So now we get to the us. Well, us who, all right, there's various different people that the us could refer to. So first of all, it could refer to magistrates, civil authorities. Okay. Next, it could refer to church officers. Okay. Ecclesiastical authorities, pastors, elders, deacons. Next, it could refer to family authorities. Okay. At the top is the father, the husband, wife, older siblings, younger siblings, right? Or it could be various other authorities. Okay. Because there's more than just actually the state, the church and the family. You got school teachers, you have business owners, you got nonprofit leaders, you know, just other superiors in society. And until you are precise in answering all of these things, it's not clear. In and this is this is one thing you got to remember whenever people throw out a vague, this is why I'm saying it's it's a vague statement that was said. Okay. We don't know what type of force. We don't know what aspect of virtue and the unregion. We don't know a few means behaving inwardly or outwardly moral. We don't know when he says the God gave it to us. I mean, by nature, by grace, what's communicated in the Bible, what's communicated through natural revelation. Is he talking about the magistrate church officers, family authorities, other authorities? We don't know any of those answers. This is why tweets like this are polarizing. Okay. Because one people mean one thing, other people mean another thing. And it can also be what's called a ma in Bailey, where because it's vague, it's initially put out there to mean one thing. And when you ask them to defend it, they change their meaning. Okay. So you got to be careful with these things. But let's break down what the what the sense is in which this phrase could be true or it could be false. All right. If what he's saying is that church officers, pastors and elders may not physically coerce, unregenerate people to behave any kind of way, then he's right. Scripture nor nature teaches that. True. If he means the magistrate may not physically coerce the unregenerate to behave morally, then that is taught by scripture and nature. Absolutely. The magistrate in fact is duty bound to do that. Mm-hmm. Do duty bound to do that. Okay. If he's talking about other authorities in society, family authorities or just private persons, then it depends. It depends. It actually does depend. So think about this. If you are a, I'm trying to think we get an example here. There's lots of various things that people in society may or may not do that may or may count as force. And depending on the scenario, they may or may not do it. Okay. So for example, if I can see a carry like every patriot should and in Florida, it would constitutional to do that. All right. And a bad guy wants to come and steal something from me as a private person, not as as a church officer. Okay. I'm not even a magistrate. Okay. I'm not this guy's dad. All right. Just private person. Okay. I actually, if they are intending to harm me or do something like that, harm someone I love, I'm about to physically coerce that person into acting morally. One way or another, where it's some jiu-jitsu, whether it's brandishing, we're going to have some physical coercion. It's going to force that person to act morally. Okay. And that every, this is what you should do in that scenario. It's self-defense. It's preventative. Okay. You're trying to keep them from doing something. They're going to regret. Okay. Et cetera, et cetera, et cetera. So there's all sorts of things that this thing could mean. And until he's very precise about who the us is, what he means by force, what exactly he's trying to say about behaving morally and where God gave us that solution, it's just a meaningless thing to say. Okay. So James, I love to agree with you. And I'm going to disagree with you on this one a little bit. Just a little bit. Let me give a little pushback on this because when I read this tweet, because you're being very charitable and you're thinking through this, and I think that the walkthrough is really helpful. I think that's really helpful for us to break down the terms. So no complaints there. This is my complaint, or not complaint pushback. I don't think that this is necessarily a mountain Bailey. And this is the reason for it because I don't want to psychoanalyze Todd Freeler what he was thinking when he posted this, who knows? Only God in him knows. But at the same time, this is the sort of platitude that I have heard from conference speakers. This is the sort of thing. I think Johnson, do I do I feel Johnson? This is not an unheard of sort of thing to throw out there. And when pressed frequently, it's usually not a mountain Bailey. Well, let me let me explain what I mean when you read this, it's easy to be frustrated by moral decay. Who is he talking to? Christians, it seems, right? He's addressing Christians. Hey, I mean, you know, the world is not frustrated by moral decay. They may think that's not my thing. But he's saying, hey, Christians, you're frustrated by moral decay. But forcing unregenerate people to behave more morally as a solution God never gave us, I read that as a general prohibition. You may be frustrated with moral decay, Christian. However, forcing these people out there, whose behavior upsets you, that's not a solution that God gives us. So we could talk about, and this is where like if you were sitting down at a table and you were able to press Todd Frey on this question and say, listen, I'm a parent and I have children. Some of my children do not appear to be regenerate. They don't appear to love the Lord. Should I still keep them, you know, should I still ask them to behave morally within my house? I think he'd probably say yes. And that's where the mountain Bailey that you're referring to would probably come in, right? I don't think he'd say, well, you know, because again, Todd Frey is a, as a credo Baptist, he's looking at this from a kind of conversionist standpoint. So I don't think he'd say, well, if one of your children appears to be on regenerate, they can live as immorally as they want to within your home. I also don't think he would say that, you know, the magistrate at large should neglect every sort of civil code that has to do with morality because again, a basis of civil code and civil governance is morality. Civil code is inherently wrong. Do what? Murder is wrong. Yeah, murder is wrong. And it's against the law not because it's convenient for us or good for our society. It's because it is against nature and against God's word. It is wrong inherently. It's objectively wrong. So I think there could be some mountain Bailey play there. But the way this tweet is thrown out is that the worst thing for a Christian to year and for is that under a generate people behave more morally. Even with all of those sort of cognitive dissonances, even with all the mountain Bailey, I've heard this enough that that's the way I read this tweet. Yeah, I think that you're, yeah, you're right. But I just don't. So here's the problem though, is that in the, as I was listening to Phil Johnson thing he did on Christian nationalism and rhetoric, community church a little while ago for the thing that I'm writing. And he says in the same talk, basically this God never gives us the ability to force under generate people to behave more like, but then he turns right around and talks about how people who do evil stuff should be punished. They're up. Okay. So I don't know what they're saying. Yeah. Because they're saying both things at the same time. Like maybe, maybe what they're trying to say is that the civil magistrate may punish acts that are immoral, but not because they are immoral, but simply because they cause they hurt the rights of other people. Okay. So the government may never punish someone on the basis of morality. It just so happens that those things which hurt other people are also things that are immoral. That that would be a very sophisticated way to do it. And maybe that's what these guys are trying to say, but right now they're just saying two contradictory things at the same time. And that's why it's so when I reposted. I'm sorry. When I said I'm missing something like, no, I mean, because when I when I quoted to me to this, it was or quote, quote, posted this whatever the term is. I don't Twitter much. But when when I when I shared this, one of my intentions was just Westminster confession. I think it's chapter 19, subsection four, if I'm remembering correctly. But anyway, it's just this isn't all the reformed confessions. It's not just the Westminster, but it's just stating that the moral law eternally binds all creatures. And whether regenerate or unregenerate, they're called to abide by God's moral law. In other words, you don't get a pass for being immoral simply because you're not regenerate. We want them to obey from the heart. And yet the moral law is binding on them. And with all the background that James already walked through, right? Like you can obey the moral law outwardly. And yet it's not coming from a heart that wants to glorify God. And therefore it's a, you know, filthy rags before the Lord, not righteousness. We understand that. But what this is what this is seeming to do is kind of collapse everything into only regenerate people. It's almost as if the civil magistrate or civil governance is expected to bring about regeneration. That's the great fear, I think, from a quote like this is that they're expecting that the civil magistrate is somehow wielding the sword in order to promote regeneration or a or a pseudo regeneration among its people. They're saying, no, no, no, we don't want to have the state wielding the sword again. This, this came out in recent, recent comments from John Piper where it seems to, it seems to be the fear is that the civil magistrate is being expected to like wield the sword to make unregenerate people think they're regenerate or to even lead them to some sort of false regeneration. That's not what we're talking about. We're saying that when the magistrate in Romans 13, it's called the wield the sword to punish what is good. In other words, restrain it. This is one of the uses of the law that Calvin spoke of. It is to restrain evil, not just in regenerate, but in unregenerate alike. That has nothing to do with conversionism or regeneration. It is simply good for people to behave morally because God has said, this is how number one, this is how you all live, but number two, this is how society's function. That's true. Now, that's not to say that at the same time, it isn't put to use by the Holy Spirit to bring to conviction and drive them to Christ. Absolutely. It can be a means of grace, right? This can actually be a working way that God works. That's right. Yeah. So my problem, so let's just assume for a second, he's not talking about pastors, because then instead of never gave us, he would have just said never gave pastors. Like you said, let's just talk to Christians. All right. Well, this means one of two things then. And logically, it can only mean one of two things. And I've noticed, whenever I put people in the horns of a logical dilemma, they always say, you're not listening to me. That's I'm not saying that. I say the opposite. You're missing what's happening. I'm saying logically, your statement entails one of these two things, and they're both wrong. It's the premise. If the premise is faulty, though the whole, you may be inconsistent. And you may hold beliefs that you shouldn't hold given logic, but this is logically what your statement entails. The less it inconsistencies, as someone once said, that's right. Yeah. So on the one hand, if this is saying, he, let's assume for a second, he believes that Christians may hold the office of the magistrate. Christians may be magistrates. Okay. In that case, what he's saying is Romans 13's false. Because Romans 13 clearly says, listen to this, for he, the magistrate is God's servant for your good. But if you do wrong, be afraid. He doesn't bear the sword in vain. For he is the servant of God, an avenger who carries out God's wrath on those who violate the rights of others. No. On the wrong doer. He is there. Okay. To threaten people so that they don't do what is morally wrong, or else they'll get the sword, and therefore is physically coercing them, forcing them to behave morally. Right. That's the magistrate. So either he does think Christians can be magistrates, and therefore is denying Romans 13 because he's saying magistrates can't do this, or he's saying, yes, magistrates are supposed to do that, but Christians aren't allowed to do that. The us is Christians, so therefore Christians can't be a magistrate. So either he's saying magistrate can't do that, or he's saying Christians can't be magistrates. It's one or the other. That's one. Yeah. But I don't act, but he will deny both those things. So what are we doing? We just seem to be happy denying things that are logically contradictory. I think one of the things that we're trying to say, or is he trying to say something else? You know, what are these guys actually trying to say? Because the other thing that it could mean is well, God doesn't allow us to punish, to force people to behave morally regarding some things, but not other things. And basically, however influential liberalism has been decides where that line is drawn. So that you could say, yes, the magistrate is supposed to punish people who murder other people. Yes. But Christians can't believe the magistrates should punish those who are homosexual. And it's like, that's why the whole, that's why the discussion is around like blasphemy, for example, because blasphemy has been in the, in the, and I have to assume that because this is a public channel, and this is very, very tied into like the current debates, what are the debates we're having? We're debating over things like Christian governance, we're debating over things like blasphemy laws, those sort of things. So book just came out, Al Moulor contributed hypothetical scenario. I think you and I talked about it on the channel at one point. But anyway, blasphemy laws were part of what we were talking about. So if you were to push in on some of these things and say, should murder be wrong because it's wrong, or excuse me, should murder be illegal, not just, not just counted as a sin within the church, but a crime within the state, because it's wrong. I think he would say, yes, I would assume he would have to, what about blasphemy laws then? And again, you could talk about what's wise and what's prudential. We've done this on this channel so many times and you may say, we're not in a spot to try to enact that law. It would actually damage the commonwealth as a post promoting good and virtue. Okay, fine. But should ought like what, what, what, what is the moral impetus? And that's where the premise becomes, becomes important because civil obedience is not saving righteousness. And I feel like what we're doing is just collapsing the two into each other. I don't know how to read this other than a protest against Christians wanting any sort of civil restraint of moral decay that like you just pointed out is not part of what's already publicly accepted. That's right. So if you were to look out and say, it's wrong that people are murdering, we should do something about that. That's fine. Go with God, you sound Christian. However, if you're to push that into any uncomfortable sphere that is still clearly part of God's moral law, then we need to back off of it. Yeah, that's right. That's right. Yeah, I don't know. It's insane. It's wrong. That's really where we need to land land. I would say this too. I think I think one of the things with this and you and I know several guys who are doing really good work in this area. But as a conflation between, it's like a dichotomy. It's a bifurcation, this radical splitting of heart between moral transformation and moral restraint. Okay. And a lot of this, I have benefited so much from Kuiper and Bob Inc over the years. And I appreciate so much of that. But it's sort of, I think in a lot of ways it's a neocipurianism. We don't need to go down that whole road. But there's this expectation that what we really need is moral transformation. We want souls to be saved. We want just more and more people to be true regenerate Christians. And that will transform society. And it puts that as if it's at odds with civil governance still doing still doing what civil governance is called to do, which is to punish evil and reward what's good. Those two things aren't in conflict. We don't need 98% of the nation to be inwardly, spiritually, regenerately moral, to say we should probably have some good moral laws though and some good ways of moral restraint. Which again, that's not just that's not a pragmatic argument. That is it like you just laid out. That is the command of Romans 13. And I think so many of these discussions wind up just collapsing those distinctions into each other or bifurcating them apart so much. You can have good laws and you can also have a church that wants to see hearts saved. Those two things are not in conflict with one another. But you don't want to be the one who agreed together. Actually, they worked great together. Yeah. Yeah. It's one of those discussions where when you really start trying to figure out what they're saying, it's just really hard to engage even in the conversation because it doesn't it doesn't make any sense. It just doesn't make any sense. Do we, you know, are there some moral things that the magistrate can't enforce? We all acknowledge yes. Okay, there are some aspects of morality that are unenforceable. Okay. And not every sin is a crime. Not every sin is a crime. You know, you can't people always point out, no, we don't want the government to enforce the tin commandments because how you're going to enforce the tin commandment, you know, against basically against envy, right? You want stuff God hasn't given you the belongs to other people. Okay. And the reform tradition has always like has always said, when we talk about the government enforcing the tin commandments, we're talking about those aspects of the tin commandments that are external and enforceable. We're not so by definition. We're not at, you know, I could go to, you know, let's even in the ancient, in the old times, you can't blasphemy, you can't punish blasphemy of the heart. You can only punish blasphemy that's externalized. Right. You know about it and censure it, right? Right. And generally punishments don't change people's minds. They may actually, but they, you can't guarantee it. Okay. So you can't say I'm going to punish you to change your mind. You know, how do you know they're not lying? So it's just, it's just, it's very frustrating. And it's impractical. But man, people really like it. They really like these phrases. They go viral. People love it. They, they do go viral. And I, I would just say this is, this is one without being the snobbish reformed guy. But this, this, this is a good encouragement that when you have things like creeds and confessions, when you have things like a reform tradition, even knowing men can and do air, it still gives you a groundwork to approach these things. So you could read a tweet like this and say, well, every major reform confession says the opposite. And there's a lot of really good scriptures that they're referencing. They're not just making this out of thin air. That's actually born from scriptural study. It gives you a framework that I hope because again, the word reformed to get stretched so, so wide and so broad. But for those who were reformed, we simply don't have to do this. We don't have to do this sort of click baitie Christianity where we throw out things that would ultimately like James was pointing out. It would ultimately destroy the social fabric if you actually applied it. We don't have to do that. We can actually say we've got some good ground rules. We don't need to reinvent the wheel on this one. We can always be studying and reforming. But at the same time, we don't have to just do the Christianity of the moment, the Christianity of our generation that just remakes and reimagines all these moral categories. The other thing to think about here too is, man, does it really turn you into Andy Stanley? Yeah. It really turns you into Andy Stanley. And let me tell you why, you are unhitching yourself from the Old Testament because at some level, you've got to reckon with the fact that God in the Old Testament did, in fact, tell the kings of Israel to force unregenerate people to behave more or more morally. Okay. And judge them when they didn't. And judge them and judge the nation in the kings when they did not do that. Yeah. Okay. The solution that's offered for that is, well, that was typological. Okay. That was supposed to point us to Christ, which is true. It is typological. Okay. But it was also a dang great way to run a nation. Okay. And it was certainly not evil or wrong. Certain will both you cannot say that, right? You can't look back and say what God did was actually wrong now. That's right. That's right. That's right. That's right. And in fact, all the nations, we're going to look at Israel and said, who has laws like these are amazingly wise law, who's God is like the law giver of Israel or the God of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob, they're supposed to admire the justice. Think about it. We go read all the Psalms about the how perfect the law is not just as a typological pointing to Christ, but also as a well constituted polity. Okay. Now, people would come back and say one or two things. They would say, well, but you've got to take into account the cultural context. So it was great for then. Does it mean it's great for now? Granted. Everyone grants that. Second, he gave that to Israel. He didn't give it to us. I get all of that. I'm trying to yes, granted. He did not give the Israelite polity to us today, granted that was for their cultural context, not ours. But I can't get over the fact that it sure seems like people who push this direction are going to have a really hard time loving and admiring the laws God gave to Israel for their cultural context. Yeah. So how are those things calling you to appreciate God's justice? Or do you always have to do apologetics? That's always a great test for your own political philosophy is when most of the time that you spend explaining the laws of Israel are spent doing apologetics. Well, this isn't really what it meant. Well, really, really, you know, really meant that. And you got it. It's like, these are just listen, these aren't iron clad rules I'm laying down now. I typically do try to lay down iron clad rules. These aren't iron clad rules. They're more like testing your heart, which is really important because you got to remember that the Old Testament civil laws were meant to lead you to a door God. You know, so you know, guys don't nail me on this. You know, like I said, not iron clad rule, but it's just I do wonder just from a heart posture how this kind of theology really keeps you from appreciating the justice of God given to the Israelites. Yeah. Good test case, by the way, for this. And maybe we can we probably need to close here, but good test case and good homework assignment. Read Calvin on the three uses of the law. It's one of the things that we bring up in credential exams. It's it's it's a good question, especially for ministers, but it's a good question for Christians. Look at Calvin's three uses of the law and how the law is good. The law is not your enemy and the law certainly not in contradiction to God's grace at work. But also don't call don't don't collapse every barrier between sin and civil code church and magistrate don't don't collapse all these things. The church is not called to write civil codes, but that doesn't mean the magistrate isn't called to wield a sword against even the unregion of the pursuit of a moral society. I got one more zinger. Oh, yeah. This this this one is a zinger, but it is true. Okay, so I know this one's going to hurt our registered radio fans, but just meditate on what I'm about to say. This is super Catholic. Here's what I mean. This sounds like an argument the Pope's been making against capital punishment. Yeah. You know, it doesn't this prove that you know the Pope's right, the Christian shouldn't support capital punishment. It doesn't matter if it's for you know child abuse or rape or murder. God never gave us the ability to force the undergenre to behave more morally. So yeah, anyway, there you go. Well, that was the that was the lead in that was our hook at the beginning of the show. Yeah, well, I like it here. In the Vatican, having come in. Yeah, I do. It's got my word. Don't give don't give our producers ideas. All right, well do this. If you have any questions on this thoughts, reach out to us. You can hit us up on email at eschatologymatters1.gmail.com. You can text James. I'll share his phone number on all socials and put it on search engine results. And you can also leave a comment and we have we have production staff that usually lets us know any any comments rolling through and we'd love to hear from you. But James is always man. Hope this has been beneficial and always good to see brother. I know if that we learn one thing from this, let's all pray that the magistrate would force the unruge in it to behave more morally. Amen. Amen. Amen.